essie mint candy apple vs Kokie Citrus Splash

Two pastel green nail polish bottles on aqua background: essie mint candy apple (L), Kokie Citrus Splash (R)

This page contains affiliate links and this site earns from qualifying purchases made through these sponsored links. 

Below discover the similarities and differences between essie mint candy apple and Kokie Citrus Splash.

essie mint candy apple is defined by essie as an adorable crème de menthe mint nail polish. You could also call it a pastel green nail polish. 

Kokie Citrus Splash is also a mint nail polish that could be defined as a pastel green.

These polishes look very similar when swatched side-by-side, however there are some differences.

First, let’s talk about the shared traits of these two polishes.

essie mint candy apple and Kokie Citrus Splash have a small handful of things in common. 

They’re both:

• Perfect for spring

• Pastel, mint green nail polishes with a creme finish

• Opaque in two coats

• Bestsellers: last year for essie, currently for Kokie

• Committed to respecting the environment and those who live in it: Kokie is cruelty-free and Leaping Bunny Certified, and as of the end of 2020, essie is offering an 8-free, 100% vegan portfolio

Let’s start this comparison by looking at a 2022 bestseller for essie, mint candy apple:

essie mint candy apple bottle on aqua background

essie mint candy apple swatch

essie mint candy apple swatch

essie mint candy apple 724

mint candy apple is a cooler-toned pastel mint green nail polish that leans blue. Shown in two coats, mint candy apple is easy to apply.

Kokie Citrus Splash bottle on aqua background

Kokie Citrus Splash swatch

Kokie Citrus Splash swatch

Kokie Citrus Splash NP24

Shown in two coats, Citrus Splash is a warmer-toned pastel mint green nail polish that leans slightly yellow.

Two pastel green nail polish bottles on aqua background: Kokie Citrus Splash (L), essie mint candy apple (R)

The main differences between essie mint candy apple and Kokie Citrus Splash are:

• mint candy apple leans blue, Citrus Splash leans yellow

• mint candy apple usually retails at a higher price, Citrus Splash usually retails at a lower price

• mint candy apple’s bottle contains 13.5 ml (0.46 fl oz) of formula, Citrus Splash’s bottle contains 16 ml (0.54 fl oz) of formula

These colors are so close to each other that Citrus Splash could be a great alternative for essie mint candy apple.

What do you think?

If you agree and think Citrus Splash is a close match to mint candy apple, it gets better.

Kokie’s polishes are an overall greater value for what you pay - you do get roughly 18% more formula for 40% less money when comparing average retail price points.

However, mint candy apple is unique - it is a bluer, more oceanic color.

Still deciding which one is right for you?

If you are looking for a greater value, and you need or prefer a warmed-toned mint green, get Kokie Citrus Splash. If price is not a concern, and you need or prefer a cooler-toned mint green, get essie mint candy apple.

Other Articles You May Enjoy:

• Teal Nails

• Pastel Nail Colors

• Green Glitter Nail Polish Swatches

• OPI Gelato on My Mind Swatch

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.